STEILYSIDE PCDGPA Club Championships Aug 3 2013 Page Title Module
Move Remove Collapse
X
Conversation Detail Module
Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Disc Golf Armory
    started a topic STEILYSIDE PCDGPA Club Championships Aug 3 2013

    STEILYSIDE PCDGPA Club Championships Aug 3 2013

    WSS C tier event
    2 rounds at steily (sat), with 1 round at Riverside (sun)
    open to all, club members get a shirt
    $55 open
    $45 am
    $35 rec
    everyone will get lunch with entry
    sign up at DiscGolfScene.com
    9am players meeting on saturday at steily and 10am on sunday at Riverside
    email mkilmer13@gmail.com with any questions

  • ericedge
    replied
    Hey Mark,

    There's a pretty good chance I could help you with the details of the admin side of the tourney. Feel free to give me a shout if you want to tap into my experience. I learned all this stuff the hard way (plenty of mistakes) so believe me, I know what it's like.

    Cheers, EE 206-850-5779

    Leave a comment:


  • Disc Golf Armory
    replied
    time

    Originally posted by KCunique View Post
    Yeah buddy! Its all fixed. Thanks
    All in due time still have to fix some divisions but I can not with out the help of the PDGA. Will be fixed when the report is turned in.

    Leave a comment:


  • KCunique
    replied
    Yeah buddy! Its all fixed. Thanks

    Leave a comment:


  • REDFIVE
    replied
    Ratings are fixed. Thanks Mark.

    Leave a comment:


  • REDFIVE
    replied
    It looks like the course pars were entered differently for some divisions. The pars should be 57, 57, and 54. Not all of the divisions +, -, add up correctly. It would be nice to know what the correct ratings are. I feel that waiting on ratings takes away from an event.
    Last edited by REDFIVE; August 5th, 2013, 11:33 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • KCunique
    replied
    Thanks Eric for the explanation! I am not fully aware of the complications of being a TD. A fix to this would be super appreciated, Mark. I'm interested to see what the actual ratings look like. Thanks for everything.

    Kenny

    Leave a comment:


  • ericedge
    replied
    Here's how it works...

    When a TD sanctions an event the PDGA sends the TD a code which enables him/her to access the admin part of the PDGA website for their event. It's up to the TD to input the different courses and/or course layouts into the system and to define which course/layout each division is playing in each round. Everyone playing a particular course at the same time will get the same rating for the same score. It appears that from what players are posting in this thread that everyone played the same exact courses at the same time. It's important to note that if a division is playing the same course but has a shortened tee for even just one hole then that's considered a different course. So, if everyone played the same courses then Gene McConnell's third round 62 (rated 885) in the Adv. Masters division should have been rated the same at James McLaughlin's 62 (rated 820) in the intermediate division. This can be fixed anytime the TD is motivated to sign onto the website and input the correct information. The same can be said for misspelled names and incorrect PDGA numbers. Not sure how to spell someone's name? If their PDGA number is there then just click on their name and bingo, you've got it.

    Leave a comment:


  • TreeLove
    replied
    Originally posted by jeverett View Post

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by KCunique View Post
    Everyone played the same course, same layout, and the same time for all 3 rounds.

    I guess I'm just wondering if its something that needs to be fixed?

    ++

    Oh.. then yes, providing each division played under the same rules (e.g. sometimes MA3 divisions have lessened OB penalties or use different tees), the same score for the round absolutely should come out with the same rating. That would definitely be a problem with the TD report.
    Correct.

    Leave a comment:


  • jeverett
    replied
    Originally posted by KCunique View Post
    Everyone played the same course, same layout, and the same time for all 3 rounds.

    I guess I'm just wondering if its something that needs to be fixed?
    Oh.. then yes, providing each division played under the same rules (e.g. sometimes MA3 divisions have lessened OB penalties or use different tees), the same score for the round absolutely should come out with the same rating. That would definitely be a problem with the TD report.

    Leave a comment:


  • jeverett
    replied
    Originally posted by KCunique View Post
    ..and that's the case for rounds 2&3, but not round 1. All 3 rounds were on 3 different courses, so the ratings changing from one round to the next is understandable.
    Was the event split into different pools, though? e.g. pool A plays course A in round 1, while pool B plays course B? Then they switch for round 2? If so, the ('unofficial') ratings are coming out just as they should, with the same score potentially having a very different rating. That *may* get fixed during the 'official' ratings process, depending on if the PDGA deems the round 1 pool A group played on course A was 'close enough' to the conditions that round 2 pool B played on that same course.

    Sorry if I'm confusing you.. I don't know anything about how that specific event was organized.

    Leave a comment:


  • KCunique
    replied
    Originally posted by jeverett View Post
    Did they play the same course and layout (with the same rules) at the same time? If so, that would be an error with the TD report. In the TD report, the TD must specifically label which division(s) played which course(s) (and layouts) each round.. and may have made a mistake there. Does that help at all?
    Everyone played the same course, same layout, and at the same time for all 3 rounds.

    I guess I'm just wondering if its something that needs to be fixed?

    Leave a comment:


  • KCunique
    replied
    ..and that's the case for rounds 2&3, but not round 1. All 3 rounds were on 3 different courses, so the ratings changing from one round to the next is understandable.

    Leave a comment:


  • jeverett
    replied
    Originally posted by KCunique View Post
    Ok, but what I'm saying is that two people with the same score on the same round ares rated differently. How is that possible?
    Did they play the same course and layout (with the same rules) at the same time? If so, that would be an error with the TD report. In the TD report, the TD must specifically label which division(s) played which course(s) (and layouts) each round.. and may have made a mistake there. Does that help at all?

    Leave a comment:


  • KCunique
    replied
    Originally posted by jeverett View Post
    That discrepancy doesn't (potentially) get fixed until the 'official' ratings. The PDGA compares the results for subsequent rounds on the same layout, and makes a determination as to if the results are 'close enough' to be combined for SSA and round rating purposes. If so, in the 'official' ratings, the same score each round will have the same rating. If not, in the 'official' ratings, the rounds will be rated as they are right now, with the same score in different rounds having a different rating. The PDGA has not published what their criteria is for determining 'close enough', but I would guess that a 48-point swing, providing a reasonable field size (number of propagators) is probably a statistically-significant difference in scoring spread (i.e. the rounds won't be combined). Unless perhaps there are other rounds that are coming out in that gap?
    Ok, but what I'm saying is that two people with the same score on the same round ares rated differently. How is that possible?

    Leave a comment:

Announcement Announcement Module
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Working...
X